Junk food… Good or Bad?
Banning junk food may seem like a morally responsible decision, but there are some issues that need to be considered before jumping to an opinion. Obesity is a growing problem and some think schools should ban junk food. But would banning junk food really solve the obesity problem? Think about it… Junk food is not the only component in obesity and should not be banned from schools. Not only does banning junk food make kids want more of it, it doesn’t help students learn how to make correct decisions such as eating healthy. The biggest problem with banning junk food though, is defining what junk food is. Where do you draw the junk food line? And who makes those decisions? These are all important issues to consider before saying no to junk food.
First, putting a ban on junk food could make students overindulge later when they are able to get it. Similarly, when people reach the age of 21, many drink too much just because they have the new freedom. A lot of 21 year olds get sick from alcohol poisoning their first few years of being able to drink. More than 150,000 college students obtain injuries from alcohol poisoning every year. Students, likewise, might eat too much junk food when they get home from school. Often times, putting a ban on something only makes people want it more. “They (students) may even eat more junk food as an act of a rebellion.” (Newman). Kids would go home and pig out on junk food just because they are denied it at school, or they would find a way to smuggle it into the schools.
Secondly, decision-making is a very important part of the high school experience. Students need to learn how to make good choices like eating healthy. “Taking away junk food does not teach students to eat healthy; it simply removes some of their options.” (Dively). Once students are out of high school, the whole world is open to them. Some may not know how to stay away from junk food without the previous essential high school exposure. Also, parents and students should have the option of choosing to eat healthy. Phyllis Schlafly says that parents who want their kids to eat healthy can send them with a lunch bag from home. (178). Even if some parents are incapable of sending their kids with better lunches, students should have enough will power to choose for themselves and motivate themselves to eat healthy.
Lastly, is the problem of defining junk food. If you take soda out of vending machines, do you also have to ban Powerade? High fructose corn syrup is the second ingredient in a Powerade. Should it still be allowed? The pizza, hamburgers, fries, chicken nuggets, and corndogs that are common in school cafeterias are not healthy, but would not necessarily be considered junk food. Would you have to ban those too? Some of those foods are worse than those in the vending machines. What would school lunches be composed of? If there weren’t as many choices for school lunch, not as many students would buy lunch. Many would take lunch from home or go out to local fast food restaurants. This would mean lots of leftovers and less money for the school.
Richard J. Codey says, “School is where children spend the most time and it is where we lay the foundation for healthy habits.” This, though thought provoking, is untrue. Two out of three meals are spent at home including what most people consider to be the most important meal- breakfast. As for the foundation of healthy habits, this should be developed at home at a young age. If students don’t know enough about nutrition by the time they start middle school, then it is a parenting flaw. However, this does not mean that schools should not reinforce teachings about nutrition on students and encourage them to eat healthy. All this can be done without banning junk food. You’re probably thinking about how junk food causes many harmful diseases. This may be the extreme of eating too much of it. A little junk food does not take over the body and force into an unhealthy lifestyle. In fact, a balanced diet consists of a little sugar and fat. Athletes also need to eat more calories in order to stay healthy for their sport. If students are careful with their junk food intake, then it would be unnecessary to ban it. It is important for students and parents to decide what is best for them, not the school board. How else are students going to learn from experience?
I do not deny that junk food is a part of obesity and obesity is a problem. But, schools should be doing their best to address it without putting a complete ban on junk food. Banning junk food in schools could make students overindulge later. Also, decision making is an important part of growing up, and there is the problem of defining junk food. Because of these main reasons a junk food ban is a careless and close-minded decision. This country is based on personal freedoms, so let’s make sure it stays that way!
Works Cited
“Ban Junk Food in School? (Debate). – Free Online Library.” Free News, Magazines, Newspapers, Journals, Reference Articles and Classic Books – Free Online Library. 6 Sept. 2002. Web. 11 Dec. 2010. <http://www.thefreelibrary.com/Ban junk food in school? (Debate).-a094960203>.
Codey, Richard J., and John Dively. “Should States Ban Junk Food in Schools? | Scholastic.com.” Teaching Resources, Children’s Book Recommendations, and Student Activities | Scholastic.com. 2006. Web. 6 Dec. 2010. <http://www2.scholastic.com/browse/article.jsp?id=10853>.
“Junk Food Should Be Banned in Schools.” Middle School Debate Program. Web. <www.middleschooldebate>.
Newman, Debbie. “Unhealthy Food, Banning from Schools.” International Debate Education Assotiation. 6 Apr. 2008. Web. 8 Dec. 2010. <http://www.idebate.org/debatebase/topic_details.php?topicID=760>.
Schlafly, Phyllis. “Schools Should Play a Role in Fighting Childhood Obesity.” Obesity: Opposing Viewpoints. Farmington Hills: Greenhaven, 2006. 177-80. Print.
Yeoman, Barry. “School Lunches Cause Childhood Obesity.” Food: Opposing Viewpoints. Farmington Hills: Greenhaven, 2006. 151-58. Print.


Junk Food. Digital image. Web. 13 May 2011.
No Junk Food. Digital image. Web. 13 May 2011.




![pg-30-Gregory-Peck-_106577t[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/04/pg-30-Gregory-Peck-_106577t1-22ybb71.jpg)
![1285345032-tokillamockingbird[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/04/1285345032-tokillamockingbird1-1xh19lm.jpg)
![easter-traditions-image-7-585399180[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/04/easter-traditions-image-7-5853991801-1u7klvl-300x218.jpg)
![easter-traditions-image-3-935368963[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/04/easter-traditions-image-3-9353689631-100fl5e.jpg)
![ApoloOhnocover[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/04/ApoloOhnocover1-1ndqcmp-150x150.jpg)
![ApoloOhno[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/04/ApoloOhno1-1ibohev.png)




![3220422264_4c3f4fb663[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/02/3220422264_4c3f4fb6631-1vpoakx-150x150.jpg)
![sheet-music[1]](http://tmisddunmire.edublogs.org/files/2011/02/sheet-music1-20w6iup-150x150.jpg)
